Who's the best defender in the Premiership?

[Beefy]

Of all the defenders in the Premiership, taking in any nationality who's the best defender currently playing?

[Jay]

vidic and carvalho. I dont think anyone else has even come close this season.

[sportbilly]

my fantasy team sez Laursen at villa

[DerbyDave]

Rio is for sure.

[Kelly]

Rio, Vidic and Carvallho, no-one else comes close. Wes Brown and Patrice Evra are best at full back.

[lfc junkie]

Originally Posted by Kelly

Rio, Vidic and Carvallho, no-one else comes close. Wes Brown and Patrice Evra are best at full back.

Stop taking those funny pills kelly, they arent doing you any good!
Wes Clown best fullback? What next? Darren Fletcher best attacking midfielder? Carvalho? didnt you see his howler against Man utd? I think Carra is the better man of all of them.

[Beastly]

I think Vidic Is the best by far hahaha Wes brown funniest thing i heard all day

[lfc junkie]

Originally Posted by Beastly

I think Vidic Is the best by far hahaha Wes brown funniest thing i heard all day

No Ferdinand is the best, Vidic's positional play is very poor. he has great potential but he isnt that good.

My vote is Carragher, the only man at liverpool, along with Torres, that didnt underperform in december and january

[Beastly]

Originally Posted by lfc junkie

No Ferdinand is the best, Vidic's positional play is very poor. he has great potential but he isnt that good.

along with Torres

mmm isnt he a striker Also Plug is better than Vidic Good one

[Darren]

Fancy Junkie nominating a Liverpool player whatever next?