Who's the best defender in the Premiership?

[lfc junkie]

Originally Posted by Darren

Fancy Junkie nominating a Liverpool player whatever next?

I'm neutral on this. A good defender is a quiet defender. No flashy things, just the decent stuff. Carra hasnt made a mistake this season. Carnavalho did, vidic did.

How is Titus Bramble doing?

[Darren]

Originally Posted by lfc junkie

I'm neutral on this. A good defender is a quiet defender. No flashy things, just the decent stuff. Carra hasnt made a mistake this season. Carnavalho did, vidic did.

How is Titus Bramble doing?

Everyone is biased Junkie, and it's understandable. I noticed Kelly nominated Manchester United players so you're not alone. It certainly wouldn't be a Newcastle defender that's for sure.

[Kelly]

All I'm saying is this. What team has the best defensive record in The premiership? Answer:- Man Utd. And who has that defence consisted of for the majority of the season? Brown - Rio - Vidic - Evra. The proof is in the statsBut I also rate Carvallho as one of the very bestNo funny pills, nothing.

[lfc junkie]

Originally Posted by Kelly

All I'm saying is this. What team has the best defensive record in The premiership? Answer:- Man Utd. And who has that defence consisted of for the majority of the season? Brown - Rio - Vidic - Evra. The proof is in the statsBut I also rate Carvallho as one of the very bestNo funny pills, nothing.

wes brown is awful. He wouldnt be outstanding if he was playing for Derby County.
Chelsea has more clean sheets btw, so much for the stats. And carvalho HASNT played well, they're going to replace him (Sergio Ramos will take his position next year)

[Beefy]

I was shocked to see that Wes Brown has played more games for Man Utd than any other player, how the hell did he manage that. John Terry, Vidic or Jonathan Woodgate(when fit) are the best in my opinion.

[Jay]

Originally Posted by lfc junkie

wes brown is awful. He wouldnt be outstanding if he was playing for Derby County.
Chelsea has more clean sheets btw, so much for the stats. And carvalho HASNT played well, they're going to replace him (Sergio Ramos will take his position next year)

nah ramos would be used at right back i think but hes already said its an honour to be linked with the big clubs but he wants to retire in madrid so it dont look like were gonna be getting him.